Factors Affecting Sport-Related Concussion Non-Disclosure in Women's Rugby-A Multi-Country Qualitative Analysis

J Funct Morphol Kinesiol. 2024 Dec 18;9(4):277. doi: 10.3390/jfmk9040277.

Abstract

Background and Objectives: Collision-sport athletes, such as rugby players, are at risk of sport-related concussion (SRC). Women are known to be at higher risk of SRC and may experience more severe and chronic symptomology than men. Knowledge of the factors that affect a player's disclosure of their concussive symptoms could help to inform strategies to improve compliance with reporting and management of head injuries. The aim of this study was to investigate the factors that may impact women rugby players' disclosure of a concussion. Methods: Twenty-eight adult (≥18 years of age) elite and semi-elite women rugby players from the UK and Ireland (n = 17) and the United States (n = 11) were interviewed on their playing background and SRC experience in women's rugby via one-on-one interviews (UK and Ireland) or an online questionnaire (US). Results: SRC data were analysed inductively using a thematic analysis approach to determine the potential reasons for SRC non-disclosure in women's rugby. Four main themes were identified which may influence a player's SRC non-disclosure: 1. women rugby players are self-managing SRC; 2. work-related concerns impact on SRC disclosure; 3. players and support staff lack knowledge on SRC management; and 4. poor internal and external communication affect the support players receive when injured. Conclusions: The findings were consistent across players from different countries. This research highlighted several factors that may impact on women rugby players' disclosure of SRC regardless of country of origin (UK, Ireland, or US) and access to concussion care. Coaches and management teams should be aware of these reasons, which may enhance how they discuss and manage concussion. There is a clear need for further education on concussion for players and support staff and for strategies to create environments where women can openly discuss their concussion concerns.

Keywords: collision sport; female athlete; injury reporting; mild traumatic brain injury; rugby code.

Grants and funding

No funding was provided for the UK and Ireland part of this study. The American part of the study was partially funded by a University of Delaware Unidel Distinguished Graduate Scholars Fellowship and a University of Delaware Department of Kinesiology and Applied Physiology Dissertation Grant.