The ultrashort peptide N-fluorenylmethoxycarbonyl-phenylalanyl-phenylalanine (FmocFF) has been largely investigated due to its ability to self-assemble into fibrils (100 nm-μm scale) that can form a sample-spanning gel network. The initiation of the gelation process requires either a solvent switch (water added to dimethyl sulfoxide) or a pH-switch (alkaline to neutral) protocol, both of which ensure the solubility of the peptide as a necessary step preceding gelation. While the respective gel phases are well understood in structural and material characteristics terms the pregelation conditions are known to a lesser extent. The question we asked is to what extent the gel-forming fibrils are already partially formed, i.e., oligomers or protofibrils. Focusing on the pregelation conditions for the pH-switch method, we investigated the self-assembly of soluble FmocFF aggregates in alkaline pH by UV circular dichroism, IR, vibrational circular dichroism, and 1H NMR spectroscopy for different peptide concentrations and more systematically as a function of temperature. The temperature dependence of the UVCD spectra of FmocFF in H2O and D2O revealed a complicated isotope effect that affects the peptide backbone and fluorene conformations in peptide aggregates differently. Moreover, we found that the melting of formed aggregates depends on peptide concentration in a nonmonotonic way. At 20 mM the UVCD data revealed the population of at least two different thermodynamic intermediate states, which seem to differ in terms of the relative arrangement of the fluorene moiety. The IR spectrum of this sample at room temperature indicates an antiparallel β-sheet arrangement, as suggested earlier in the literature. However, we show that this interpretation can only be valid if one invokes a nondispersive redshift of the two amide I' bands in a locally crystalline environment. The respective vibrational circular dichroism spectrum of the amide I' region is consistent with a left-handed helically twisted structure of the formed aggregates. A comparison of our data with spectra of the aqueous gel phase suggests that fibrils in the latter resemble the ones at alkaline pH probed by our experiments.