Performance-based habitat choice can drive rapid adaptive divergence and reproductive isolation

Abstract

Theory predicts that performance-based habitat choice^1,2,3-where individuals select environments based on their local performance-should be widespread in nature and significantly influence ecological and evolutionary processes, including local adaptation, population divergence, reproductive isolation, and speciation.^{2,4,5,6,7,8,9} However, experimental evidence supporting these predictions has been largely lacking. In this study, we addressed this by inducing performance-based habitat choice in wild tree sparrows (Passer montanus) through the manipulation of differential access to transponder-operated feeders in two adjacent woodland areas. Sparrows overwhelmingly chose to move to and breed in the area where their feeding performance was highest, leading to local adaptation and increased reproductive success. Moreover, this non-random movement led to a high degree of assortative mating for transponder type and to reproductive isolation with respect to this ecological trait-all within a single generation. Our findings provide an empirical proof of principle that performance-based habitat choice can drive adaptive population divergence, even in the absence of divergent natural selection, underscoring its potential role as a key mechanism in ecological and evolutionary dynamics. This highlights the importance of integrating performance-based habitat choice into broader frameworks of adaptation and speciation, especially in the context of rapidly changing environments.

Keywords: adaptive divergence; assortative mating; gene flow; habitat selection; local adaptation; matching habitat choice; natural selection; population divergence; reproductive isolation; speciation.