ACKR3, an atypical chemokine receptor, has been associated with prothrombotic events and the development of cardiovascular events. We designed, synthesized, and evaluated a series of novel small molecule ACKR3 agonists. Extensive structure-activity relationship studies resulted in several promising agonists with potencies ranging from the low micromolar to nanomolar range, for example, 23 (EC50 = 111 nM, Emax = 95%) and 27 (EC50 = 69 nM, Emax = 82%) in the β-arrestin-recruitment assay. These compounds are selective for ACKR3 versus ACKR2, CXCR3, and CXCR4. Several agonists were subjected to investigations of their P-selectin expression reduction in the flow cytometry experiments. In particular, compounds 23 and 27 showed the highest potency for platelet aggregation inhibition, up to 80% and 97%, respectively. The most promising compounds, especially 27, exhibited good solubility, metabolic stability, and no cytotoxicity, suggesting a potential tool compound for the treatment of platelet-mediated thrombosis.