We use the discrete element method, taking particle contact and hydrodynamic lubrication into account, to unveil the shear rheology of suspensions of frictionless non-Brownian rods in the dense packing fraction regime. We find that, analogously to the random close packing volume fraction, the shear-driven jamming point of this system varies in a nonmonotonic fashion as a function of the rod aspect ratio. The latter strongly influences how the addition of rodlike particles affects the rheological response of a suspension of frictionless non-Brownian spheres to an external shear flow. At fixed values of the total (rods plus spheres) packing fraction, the viscosity of the suspension is reduced by the addition of "short"(≤2) rods but is instead increased by the addition of "long"(≥2) rods. A mechanistic interpretation is provided in terms of packing and excluded-volume arguments.