Impact on the estimated dose of different tissue assignment strategies during partial breast irradiations with INTRABEAM

Abstract

Purpose: Partial breast irradiations with electronic brachytherapy or kilovoltage intraoperative radiotherapy devices such as Axxent or INTRABEAM are becoming more common every day. Breast is mainly composed of glandular and adipose tissues, which are not always clearly disentangled in planning breast CTs. In these cases, breast tissues are replaced with an average soft tissue, or even water. However, at kilovoltage energies, this may lead to large differences in the delivered dose, due to the dominance of photoelectric effect. Therefore, the aim of this work was to study the effect on the dose prescribed in breast with the INTRABEAM device using different soft tissue assignment strategies that would replace the adipose and glandular tissues that constitute the breast in cases where these tissues cannot be adequately distinguished in a CT scan.

Methods and materials: Dose was computed with a Monte Carlo code in five patients with a 3 cm diameter INTRABEAM spherical applicator. Tissues within the breast were assigned following six different strategies: one based on the TG-43 recommendations, representing the whole breast as water of unity density, another one also water-based but with CT derived density, and the other four also based on CT-derived densities, using a single tissue resulting from different mixes of glandular and adipose tissues. These were compared against the reference dose computed in an accurately segmented CT, following TG-186 recommendations. Relative differences and dose ratios between the reference and the other tissue assignment strategies were obtained in three regions of interest inside the breast.

Results and conclusions: Dose planning in water-based tissues was found inaccurate for breast treatment with INTRABEAM, as it would incur in up to 30% under-prescription of dose. If accurate soft tissue assignments in the breast cannot be safely done, a single-tissue composition of 80% adipose and 20% glandular tissue, or even a 100% adipose tissue, would be recommended to avoid dose under-prescription.

Keywords: Breast tissue composition; Low-energy X-ray IORT; Monte Carlo dose calculation; Partial breast irradiation.