Background: Information management capacity is crucial for controlling risks from health emergencies. But little is known about how sub-national public health bodies overcome public health intelligence challenges when responding to disease outbreaks. This paper describes a protocol for a mixed-methods systematic review to fill this knowledge gap. In addition to describing the evidence base and characterising public health intelligence responses, it will explore reported facilitators and barriers to response.
Methods: Research on sub-national Public Health Intelligence disease outbreak responses will be synthesised. The review will be limited to articles published in English, during or after 2019. Key electronic databases will be searched for peer-reviewed, primary research studies. Two reviewers will independently screen articles for relevance. Articles that refer to a public health intelligence response to a propagated disease outbreak by a sub-national Public Health Authority will be included. Quality assessment of included articles will be undertaken using published tools. Data integration will be by the Pillar Integration Process (PIP).
Discussion: This review will describe and synthesise the recent literature on sub-national Public Health Authorities' responses to propagated disease outbreaks. The systematic design will limit bias and the inclusion of data from quantitative, qualitative and mixed-methods studies will ensure relevant evidence is considered regardless of the methodology used to produce it. The review is part of a larger research project which aims to explore the role of sub-national public health intelligence during the COVID-19 pandemic and investigate how public health intelligence preparedness could be improved in the future. This could provide information to support the development of training, preparedness indicators and/or ways of implementing directives.
Prospero registration: CRD42022308042 (08/02/2022).
Keywords: COVID-19; Disease Outbreaks; Local Government; Public Health; Public Health Authority; Public Health Informatics; Public Health Intelligence; Public Health Systems Research.
What are the information challenges for local public health services responding to an outbreak of disease? Useful information is vital for planning public health activities. This means good information management is very important during an outbreak of disease. But little is known about how local public health bodies overcome challenges in this area. Examples of challenges could include not receiving sufficient data and/or not having enough staff to analyse it. This paper describes planned research based on a review of the literature. We want to know how local public health bodies have collected, analysed and provided useful information during disease outbreaks and what makes it easier or harder for them to do this. To make the results more reliable, the review will take a structured approach. Two people will work on some stages to check each other’s work. We will search databases of research articles to find any kind of study that describes information challenges for local public health organisations during a disease outbreak. Specific criteria will be used to judge which studies to include. To be included, studies must be about a disease that spreads from person-to-person, and they must have been published in or after 2019. Included studies will be summarised. Results will feed into further research on how local public health bodies could be better prepared for disease outbreaks in the future.
Copyright: © 2023 Parr J et al.