Time to rest a hypothesis? Accumulating evidence that periodic leg movements during sleep are not increased in children with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): results of a case-control study and a meta-analysis

Abstract

Study objectives: To address the hypothesis that periodic leg movements during sleep (PLMS) are more frequent in children with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) when compared with typically developing (TD) children. To that end, we analyzed PLMS in a recent case-control study and conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of PLMS frequency in children with ADHD and TD children.

Methods: In our case-control study, we compared the PLMS frequency of 24 children with ADHD (mean age 11 years, 17 males) to that of 22 age-matched typically developing (TD) children (mean age 10 years, 12 males). A subsequent meta-analysis included 33 studies that described PLMS frequency in groups of children with ADHD and/or groups of TD children.

Results: The case-control study did not show any differences in the frequency of PLMS between children with ADHD and TD children, a result that was consistent across a range of different definitions of PLMS, which in turn had a significant and systematic effect on PLMS frequency. The meta-analysis compared the average PLMS indices and the proportion of children with elevated PLMS indices between children with ADHD and TD children and across a number of analyses did not find any meta-analytic results that supported the hypothesis that PLMS are more frequent in children with ADHD.

Conclusions: Our results suggest that PLMS are not more frequent in children with ADHD compared with TD children. A finding of frequent PLMS in a child with ADHD should therefore be considered a separate disorder and prompt specific diagnostic and therapeutic strategies.

Keywords: attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder; case–control study; meta-analysis; periodic leg movement scoring rules; periodic leg movements during sleep.