Protein language models, trained on millions of biologically observed sequences, generate feature-rich numerical representations of protein sequences. These representations, called sequence embeddings, can infer structure-functional properties, despite protein language models being trained on primary sequence alone. While sequence embeddings have been applied toward tasks such as structure and function prediction, applications toward alignment-free sequence classification have been hindered by the lack of studies to derive, quantify and evaluate relationships between protein sequence embeddings. Here, we develop workflows and visualization methods for the classification of protein families using sequence embedding derived from protein language models. A benchmark of manifold visualization methods reveals that Neighbor Joining (NJ) embedding trees are highly effective in capturing global structure while achieving similar performance in capturing local structure compared with popular dimensionality reduction techniques such as t-SNE and UMAP. The statistical significance of hierarchical clusters on a tree is evaluated by resampling embeddings using a variational autoencoder (VAE). We demonstrate the application of our methods in the classification of two well-studied enzyme superfamilies, phosphatases and protein kinases. Our embedding-based classifications remain consistent with and extend upon previously published sequence alignment-based classifications. We also propose a new hierarchical classification for the S-Adenosyl-L-Methionine (SAM) enzyme superfamily which has been difficult to classify using traditional alignment-based approaches. Beyond applications in sequence classification, our results further suggest NJ trees are a promising general method for visualizing high-dimensional data sets.
Keywords: deep learning; hierarchical clustering; manifold visualization; protein language models; representation learning; sequence classification.
© The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press.