Perceived 10-year change in respiratory health: reliability and predictive ability

Abstract

Objective: To investigate the usefulness of a self-reported respiratory health transition question over 10 years through reliability, ability to capture long-term asthma trajectory and predictive ability.

Settings: In two 20-year cohorts (Asthma-E3N, n = 16,371, 61-88 years; EGEA, n = 1254, 27-82 years), perceived 10-year change in respiratory health ("Overall, in the last 10 years, do you think that your bronchial or respiratory health has changed?" if yes: "Has it improved/deteriorated?") was studied in relation with change in respiratory medication dispensation and lung function, with change in asthma status measured over the same period of time, and with subsequent asthma-related outcomes.

Results: Perceived deterioration (14% in Asthma-E3N) was associated with increased dispensations of respiratory medications over time (from 17% with >2 dispensations in 2004 to 26% in 2010). Report of perceived deterioration (13% in EGEA) was related to a lung function decline steeper by 9.3 mL/year as compared to perceived improvement. In both cohorts, change (improvement or deterioration) was more often perceived by participants with than without asthma (>45% vs <20%) and was dominant among participants with persistent current asthma (77%). Perceived deterioration was related to poorer asthma control 7 years later and to higher use of oral corticosteroids in the following 18 months.

Conclusion: The proposed simple self-reported respiratory health transition question over 10 years allows predicting part of the long-term trajectory of asthma.

Keywords: Asthma; Longitudinal; Perceived health; Respiratory health; Variability.