Purpose: The aim of this study was to evaluate and compare sublobar resection plus intraoperative seed implant (IOS) versus stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) in patients with single malignant lung nodules in patients 70 years of age or older.
Materials and methods: A retrospective chart review was performed and 47 patients with adequate information were selected for analysis. Thirty patients with single malignant lung nodules received SBRT. Seventeen patients received limited surgical resection plus radioactive seed implantation for solitary malignant lung nodules. Univariate statistical analysis showed a significant difference only for the age in the 2 groups: the mean age in the radioactive seed group, 78.8 years versus 76.1 years in the SBRT group (2-sided, P=0.05).
Results: There was high local control and minimal toxicity with either treatment modality and no significant difference among the 2 groups in terms of local control, survival, and toxicity. However, the distant failure was higher but not statistically significant in the SBRT group (9 of 30 patients in SBRT vs. 0 of 17 in IOS, P=0.1).
Conclusions: Our study has shown excellent outcomes and limited toxicity in both IOS and SBRT for treatment of single malignant lung nodules in patients who are not candidates for lobectomy. However, a randomized trial is needed in this group of elderly patients to determine the most appropriate treatment.