A 70-year-old man known for recurrent abdominal gastrointestinal stroma tumor presented with a suspicious peritoneal mass demonstrated by an abdominal CT scan. Whole-body PET showed focal FDG uptake in the right hip, whereas the peritoneal mass was FDG negative. Histologic work-up of the PET positive lesion surprisingly revealed a giant cell tumor of the tendon sheath. The benignity of the peritoneal mass was confirmed by its disappearance in repeated CT scans. In general, focally increased FDG uptake should be subject to further investigations, especially in localizations that are not consistent with typical metastatic pathways of the former primary tumor.