We present a case of synchronous involvement of the pineal and suprasellar regions by a mixed germ cell tumor comprising germinoma and yolk sac tumor components, with a predominant angiomatous component. To our knowledge, it is the first case of this nature to be reported in the literature. Usually, synchronous lesions of this kind are pure germinomas, and some clinicians will forgo a biopsy and assume a germinoma histology if the serum beta-human chorionic gonadotrophin (HCG) is <50 IU/l and the alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) is within normal limits. Secondly, if a biopsy is performed on a lesion that has a prominent angiomatous component, the diagnostic germ cell tumor may be missed at the time of the biopsy. In order to alert clinicians and pathologists to this rare entity, the case is discussed with particular reference to difficulties that were encountered in rendering an accurate diagnosis, and the associated management implications.