Efficacy of several antioxidants in the protection of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae mutants deficient in CuZnSOD and deficient in glutaredoxin 5 to growth restriction induced by oxidants was studied. Ascorbate and glutathione protected the Deltasod1 and Deltagrx5 mutants against the effects of t-butyl hydroperoxide and cumene hydroperoxide, Deltasod1 mutants against oxytetracycline and Deltagrx5 mutants against menadione and 2,2'-azobis-(2-amidinopropane). However, Tempol, Trolox and melatonin were much less effective, showing prooxidative effects and, at high concentrations, hampering the growth of the mutants in the absence of exogenous oxidants. These results point to a complication of cellular effects of antioxidants by their prooxidative effects and to the usefulness of cellular tests to evaluate the biological effectiveness of antioxidants.