A second allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplant (HSCT) for relapsed hematologic malignancies is an option in select patients after an initial allograft has failed. If the original donor is not available, a different donor may have to be considered. We report our experience of performing a second allogeneic HSCT using a different donor in patients with relapsed leukemia and lymphoma. In a 5-year period, six patients underwent a second allograft with myeloablative conditioning using a different donor. Four of these were retransplanted using a matched-unrelated donor. Four of the patients (67%) remain progression-free at a median follow-up of 32 months (range 3-72). There were no cases of transplant-related mortality. We conclude that a second allogeneic HSCT using a different donor is a viable option for selected patients relapsing after an allograft if the original donor is not available.