Parkinson's disease (PD) is characterized by fibrillary neuronal inclusions called Lewy bodies (LBs) consisting largely of alpha-synuclein (alpha-syn), the protein mutated in some patients with familial PD. The mechanisms of alpha-syn fibrillization and LB formation are unknown, but may involve aberrant degradation or turnover. We examined the ability of calpain I to cleave alpha-syn in vitro. Calpain I cleaved wild-type alpha-syn predominantly after amino acid 57 and within the non-amyloid component (NAC) region. In contrast, calpain I cleaved fibrillized alpha-syn primarily in the region of amino acid 120 to generate fragments like those that increase susceptibility to dopamine toxicity and oxidative stress. Further, while calpain I cleaved wild-type alpha-syn after amino acid 57, this did not occur in mutant A53T alpha-syn. This paucity of proteolysis could increase the stability of A53T alpha-syn, suggesting that calpain I might protect cells from forming LBs by specific cleavages of soluble wild-type alpha-syn. However, once alpha-syn has polymerized into fibrils, calpain I may contribute to toxicity of these forms of alpha-syn by cleaving at aberrant sites within the C-terminal region. Elucidating the role of calpain I in the proteolytic processing of alpha-syn in normal and diseased brains may clarify mechanisms of neurodegenerative alpha-synucleinopathies.