Selection line rats congenitally high or low for autotomy in the neuroma model of neuropathic pain (HA and LA rats) were found to be correspondingly high and low in a second type of neuropathic pain, the Chung model, which employs an alternative phenotypic endpoint, tactile allodynia. It has been proposed that both phenotypes reflect ectopic hyperexcitability in axotomized primary sensory neurons. To test this hypothesis we made in vitro recordings from sensory neurons in the L4 and 5 dorsal root ganglia. Baseline excitability was similar in HA and LA rats, and axotomy caused an increase in both lines. However, in the one neuronal subclass previously linked to neuropathic pain in these models the increase was significantly greater in HA than LA rats, and only at the time when pain scores in the two lines were diverging. Heritable differences in electrical response to axotomy in a specific afferent cell type appear to be a fundamental determinant of neuropathic pain.